Thumb Insurance Agency welcomes you and invites you to be part of our insurance family since 1927.

Since 1927
I
Insurance Partners
Thumb Insurance Agency has a fully licensed staff that is there to review all of your insurance needs. We are Independent Insurance Agents, who serve the needs of individuals, families and businesses. We have continued the tradition of excellence that our customers have learned to expect, long after the sale of their policy. We work on your side when you have a loss and follow through to see that you get a fair settlement when it comes to claims. With Thumb Insurance as your agency, we can and do make a difference.
Being independent allows us to quote insurance premiums from many different companies to find the best service & prices available to you. Over the years, we have gained the expertise to match the right person to the right insurance company. We offer a complete evaluation of your insurance needs by matching your requirements with a total insurance solution.

Auto-Owners Insurance
Phone:
517.323.1200
Fax:
517.323.8796
Claims:
888.252.4626

Bristol West
Phone:
888.888.0080

Fremont Insurance
Phone:
231.924.0300

Figo
Phone:
844.738.3446

Foremost Insurance Group
Phone:
888.888.0080
Claims:
800.527.3905

Hagerty Insurance
Phone:
877.922.9701
Claims:
800.922.4050

Hastings Mutual
Phone:
800.442.8277

Auto-Owners Insurance
Phone:
800.847.2886
Claims:
800.325.1088

Progressive Insurance
Phone:
800.776.4737
Claims:
800.274.4499

State Auto
Phone:
614.464.5000
Claims:
800.766.1853

Travelers
Phone:
800.842.5075
Claims:
800.252.4633

Wolverine Mutual Insurance Company
Phone:
800.733.3320